QB or NOT QB.....

Also true.
I’m super big on Williams and Maye. I think those two are special

 

Caleb is fast growing on me for sure. Maye is very intriguing too.

 

I agree, if they don't like this years QB class, running it back with Mills next year is not an option. Neither is signing a middling free agent that might win too many games.

So take a journeyman in a later round.

 

If I'm the Texans I'm picking Will Anderson with their top pick. If Young can be hd with the Cleveland pick I'd pick him there. Otherwise trade back for more picks and select Cameron Ward who has tremendous potential.

 

I’d be down with Ward after the 2nd. I think McCall has a higher chance of being a big time QB.

 

If I'm going defense, I'd pick Jalen Carter over Will Anderson. Elite player in the middle of the defense and can slide out to edge if needed. Also, this draft is deeper with edge players than elite DTs.

 

Again Im cool with that, but these yahoos might convince themselves that this NEW 3rd-4th round QB has the tools it takes to win and use that as reasoning to bypass taking a QB high next year. It could be DAvis Mills all over again as the guys y'all are talking about as possibilities I dont view as huge improvements over Mills considering the terrible system in place. I dont think any young QB will be able to succeed here with Lovie/Pep.

 

I don't necessarily agree. We saw that Kyle Allen and Jeff Driskel both looked better than Davis Mills in the preseason and by all accounts they also looked better than Mills the further training camp went along. The only reason they aren't playing is because they have no potential upside to tap in to. I think while Pep and Lovie have issues, Davis himself may have a lower cap on his potential than people are willing to admit.

Objectively he has only slightly above average arm strength, struggles with accuracy, especially to the sidelines and deep, doesn't possess great pocket awareness or elusiveness, isn't comfortable scrambling, and tends to stare down his target. He looks good for a 3rd round qb, but compared to the best qbs in the league, objectively there is no way for him to grow into that tier from a physical traits standpoint. This leaves it all up to his development mentally, and he hasn't shown any exceptional prowess in that area either.

 

The guys who are in the talks going 3-4th round are no different from Mills, Allen or Driskel though. Its a roll of the dice. Maybe some guy does break through, but for that to happen it normally requires a pretty good landing spot and this is not one of those. Why take a QB as a project again and have to wait another 3 years for him to develop and fill out the team around him. We'll be close to a decade into this rebuild before we can field an average team.

 

Draftwire is a terrible site, just so you know.
It’s bleacher report level

 

Levis is better prospect than all except Young

 

Anthony Richardson at 3 is just crazy. Have you guys watched him play? Some of the other guys on the list might just look appealing because they line up with a fan preference which is fine, but there are definitely some head scratchers on that list.

 

I’m telling y’all, Caleb is that dude

 

Caleb Williams wasn’t the No. 1 recruit in the nation. Not even the No. 1 QB in his class so remind me why we’re comparing them.