Jeez, you have to take the run though... Castro can be the greatest defensive catcher in the world, and a HR by Seattle will still tie the game.
I mean, in theory there was a chance Castro could get the run in.. Yes, a HR can tie the game. But a walk or single are more likely than a HR, and Conger behind the plate can turn that into a HR more easily
I know everyone else has already said it....but man Castro is terrible offensively....quite the struggle for him at the plate.
Naw you need him back there. It's fine for hunch to have faith that Castro could at the very least make contact.
Have you seen his overall numbers since coming back? Not to mention he hasn't come close to even making contact tonight. But this is also in theory... far more theory since you presume there will be heavy traffic on the base paths with baserunners even looking to steal.