If you were GM of an online message board and could only choose one to build around, which one would you take? Who do you think has a higher upside?
tinman plays better defense, if you don't mind lots of flopping. CH's offense ... uh, wit ... is overrated. But he hands down is more fun to play against because he actually brings some intelligent discussions to the board. That said, this kind of polls wouldn't have existed if not for tinman. So it's really a hard choice.
tinman plays drawing on his experience and is a fan of the true one whereas Carl brings a lot to the table, but ultimately is just a fan of the expendable one
Carl is genuinely humorous, while Tinman is a nostalgic prick who feels he should be respected because of his age rather than his intelect.