Official "Should I" Thread - Page 300

cloudng8 · 10-24-2012, 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lil Pun

Or, what about

SEND
M. Turner
B. Lloyd

RECEIVE
M. Floyd
S. Smith

Nope i wouldnt do it. I would take my chances that those misses turn into huge gains then settle for something less.

Lil Pun · 10-24-2012, 04:11 PM

I've sent through the M. Turner and B. Lloyd for D. Thomas and H. Nicks. We'll see if he takes it. Also sent Dwyer for Maclin.

Guess I'll see what happens.

skenney1993 · 10-24-2012, 04:24 PM

I wouldn't accept any of those offers. Nicks is getting close to 100% and Thomas is quietly a top 10 fantasy wr

juicystream · 10-24-2012, 04:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by skenney1993

I wouldn't accept any of those offers. Nicks is getting close to 100% and Thomas is quietly a top 10 fantasy wr

Depends on how deep at WR and thin at RB you are.

I can't see any chance of Dwyer for Maclin though.

Pete the Cheat · 10-24-2012, 04:49 PM

just traded Anquan Boldin & Martellus Bennet for Antonio Gates. grades?

juicystream · 10-24-2012, 04:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pete the Cheat

just traded Anquan Boldin & Martellus Bennet for Antonio Gates. grades?

F

Gates may very well be worth it, but after one good game, that isn't cheap.

BucMan55 · 10-24-2012, 05:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by juicystream

F

Gates may very well be worth it, but after one good game, that isn't cheap.

If Bolden was the 4th-5th WR then it was a good trade.....Gates has already had his bye and Bennett is a step down......

AkeemTheDreem86 · 10-24-2012, 07:10 PM

Should I trade away Fitzgerald to get Mike Wallace?

.5 PPR, 2WR 1Flex

It seems to me Fitz has a much harder schedule, not to mention a bye week left. What do y'all think?

Pete the Cheat · 10-25-2012, 02:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by juicystream

F

Gates may very well be worth it, but after one good game, that isn't cheap.

ouch...F? I feel like I am back in my college accounting class...

Boldin is on his bye this week (as is AJ Green), so I plan on using Gates as my flex W/T this week. A Hernandez is my other TE so this is also an insurance policy.

with Green on bye I would have been forced to start B Lloyd, N Washington and K Britt.

Gates is the best play between the 3 to close the season (he, Boldin or Bennet).
Baltimore only has 4 home games remaining if my memory serves, and Flacco is got garbage on the road (and by extension Boldin). M Bennet had a hot start and I still managed to salvage some trade value for him.

hopefully I did better on the written portion of my exam than the multiple choice, professor...

juicystream · 10-25-2012, 02:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pete the Cheat

ouch...F? I feel like I am back in my college accounting class...

Boldin is on his bye this week (as is AJ Green), so I plan on using Gates as my flex W/T this week. A Hernandez is my other TE so this is also an insurance policy.

with Green on bye I would have been forced to start B Lloyd, N Washington and K Britt.

Gates is the best play between the 3 to close the season (he, Boldin or Bennet).
Baltimore only has 4 home games remaining if my memory serves, and Flacco is got garbage on the road (and by extension Boldin). M Bennet had a hot start and I still managed to salvage some trade value for him.

hopefully I did better on the written portion of my exam than the multiple choice, professor...

I don't think you got any value for Bennett. Zero. Not sure you got max value for Boldin. Applaud you for trading Boldin before he lost value, but that is about it.

You failed for not maximizing either's value, or grabbing Gates at his lowest.

juicystream · 10-25-2012, 02:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AkeemTheDreem86

Should I trade away Fitzgerald to get Mike Wallace?

.5 PPR, 2WR 1Flex

It seems to me Fitz has a much harder schedule, not to mention a bye week left. What do y'all think?

PPR adds to Fitz's value (in comparison to Wallace), but his QBs are so terrible.

I'll lean towards doing it, if for no other reason than Wallace has already had his bye week.

wekko368 · 10-25-2012, 03:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by juicystream

I don't know. I don't like Sproles unless it is a PPR league. Brandon Lloyd on the high end probably, given desperation. I think you could get a #2 receiver (NFL, not fantasy) with little problem. If you can make it to the playoffs without him, I'd buy low on Amendola (maybe for less than Sproles?). I'd be tempted to test the market for Steve Smith and his 0 TDs frusturating standard league owners.

I ended up trading Sproles/Ballard/Cobb/Pitta for Ryan Mathews/Owen Daniels.

For my WR rotation, I'm left with Harvin/V.Jackson/D.Heyward-Bey.

juicystream · 10-25-2012, 06:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wekko368

I ended up trading Sproles/Ballard/Cobb/Pitta for Ryan Mathews/Owen Daniels.

For my WR rotation, I'm left with Harvin/V.Jackson/D.Heyward-Bey.

Might not have traded Cobb with Jennings looking out for a few more weeks, but better to strike while he has higher value I suppose.

I'm high on Mathews (just freaking stay health and stay out of Turner's doghouse) and Daniels >>>>>>>>>>>> Pitta.

Mr Striker09 · 10-26-2012, 11:04 AM

I have Marques Colston and was going to trade him for Lynch? You guys think it be a good trade for me to do?. Wrs ill have left would be Decker, Julio Jones, Denarius Moore, and Cobb. My RBs are Ray Rice, MCcoy, Jones Drew, and Rashad Jennings.

Stack24 · 10-26-2012, 12:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr Striker09

I have Marques Colston and was going to trade him for Lynch? You guys think it be a good trade for me to do?. Wrs ill have left would be Decker, Julio Jones, Denarius Moore, and Cobb. My RBs are Ray Rice, MCcoy, Jones Drew, and Rashad Jennings.

What positions do you have to start? I don't think there is a use in tradig for lynch based on who you have right now. I would keep Colston to have a bit more depth at WR even though you are pretty decent there.