Calling Alex Smith

I understand. My position is that he shouldn't be considered at all

 

maybe we can also replace AJ and watt with garbage as well while we're at it

 

Alex Smith's hands are tiny -- they're so small that scouts didn't think he could play in the NFL. That has nothing to do with anything, but I think Schaub is better than Smith.

 

Matt Flynn, maybe?

 

is this what we have become? alex smith?

if that is where your head is at, you should lobby for david carr instead, less wear and tear--wait, nevermind.

 

i'd rather have vince young. =/

 

We really need a mobile QB...our offense with a mobile QB would be devastating...Look what RG3 has done in his first year...i really believe in the system...and its a solid system designed to wear out a defense with the run...but there has to a threat on a boot leg...

 

GTFO Shaub! I hate you!!

 

Is RG3 available? i'm not sure when alex smith became RG3....maybe i'm baised cause i live in the bay area so i know how terrible smith is though

 

ouch...

 

I perfectly understand the Schaub hate but Alex Smith is Schaub with a little more mobility. Neither have great arm strength nor outside of their system have they been proven to be great playmakers. I'd go for Mike Vick or starting TJ Yates then Alex Smith.

 

Guessing you didn't see the playoff game against NO last year. Smith won that game for them.

 

Michael Vick and Schaub can be his backup again.

 

I agree here. Schaub is better than Smith, but I think it is now clear that he just can't seem to step up when needed. Much of this I believe has to do with constant hand holding from Kubiak... like when we are down by 25 with 10 minutes to go and Kubiak is still calling plays in slowly. Let the damn QB give it a whirl by saving us some time in the process.

 

Tebow....

 

Now we're just being silly.

 

Smith doesn't solve anything, he's another version of Schaub

acknowledge QB is a need, but sit tight with Schaub until something better comes along in the draft

just like SF did with Smith

 

The pistol is legit. RGIII, Kaepernick and Wilson all had huge success with it this year. Cam Newton and the Panthers actually looked decent with it in their triple option formations earlier in the year. It's here to stay, but as RGIII has shown us... you need a stout QB for it to be worthwhile all season.

Tebow anyone?

 

This would actually be a downgrade.

 

the guy had a different OC (6 or 7 total) every year prior to harbaugh coming on. i think his poor play was due to the team having to change offensive systems every year.