Sting - Bring on the Night I don't usually like live records but this one is really amazing. It never gets any recognition but it has some of the coolest stuff on it.
The Click - Game Related I bought it because one song was good but I can listen to just about every song but one now.
Any album by Elliott Smith. Lots of his songs are just him and his guitar singing pretty smooth. He did the Good Will Hunting soundtrack. Maxim magazine had readers vote on the most underated artist last year and he won.