Okay the Megan Fox thread got me to thinking about this as people were going on and on about how Brad Pitt is not a great actor. IMO, he isn't DeNiro or Pacino level but he is far from being a bad one. Cruise is someone that has often been accused of not being a good actor. So, Clutchfans, I ask you this question: Who is the better actor - Tom Cruise or Brad Pitt?
Tom Cruise. At least Tom totally fit the character that he's playing. Brad Pitt trying to expand his role make him look like an idiot most of the time. Troy is the one of the worst acting I've ever seen him in but the movie suck total balls anyway.
Brad Pitt's best work: Spoiler But then he was outdone by young Casey Affleck who stole the show. Tom Cruise's best work: Spoiler But then he was outdone by an aging Jack Nicholson who stole the thunder. Conclusion: Neither pretty boy is really a good actor but between the two, Pitt has made better films the last 10-15 years like Se7en, Fight Club, Babel, Inglorious Basterds, and The Curious Case of Benjamin Button.
Also, forget to mention in the above movies that Pitt was outdone by his supporting actors almost always like Mogan Freeman, Edward Norton, Christoph Waltz, and Taraji P. Henson. So, Pitt really looks bad without a solid supporting cast who somehow always manage to turn in a better performance than Pitt.
They're both megastars, which means brand recognition and repetition. Cruise's hook is intensity, Pitt's is insanity or aloofness. Overall it's a wash, but I think twenty years from now Pitt will be remembered as a better actor. Cruise may not have any more good dramatic performances left in him or just too much bad pub to overcome, some of the Valkryie reviews were just mean-spirited and quasi-bigoted.
Quasi-bigoted. A lot of crap in mutliple mainstream reviews about the "irony" of seeing Tom in a Nazi outfit. I don't like Spacechurch either, but keep it on the blogs.
No appettite for Tropic Thunder but Burn After Reading was depressingly disappointing. Did enjoy trying to identify all the allegories/analogies, though.