Just watched Vicky Christina Barcelona. My gosh, how do you choose between those two? Those are two beautiful women. Gun to my head? Cruz. No, johansson. Oy vey.
Just watched Hitchcock last night and man Scarlett's body was so damn nice in that old fashioned tight outfit. DAT ASS. She looked as best as i've ever seen her in that film!
I'm going to agree with the OP only to the extent that IN THAT MOVIE the Cruz character and the Johansson character are hard to choose between. But in real life, I'm going with R0ckets03's assessment.