Mornings in Blue America

gifford1967 · Mar 27, 2015

Merci Obama

Mornings in Blue America
MARCH 27, 2015

Paul Krugman

Two impossible things happened to the U.S. economy over the course of the past year — or at least they were supposed to be impossible, according to the ideology that dominates half our political spectrum. First, remember how Obamacare was supposed to be a gigantic job killer? Well, in the first year of the Affordable Care Act’s full implementation, the U.S. economy as a whole added 3.3 million jobs — the biggest gain since the 1990s. Second, half a million of those jobs were added in California, which has taken the lead in job creation away from Texas.

Were President Obama’s policies the cause of national job growth? Did Jerry Brown — the tax-raising, Obamacare-embracing governor of California — engineer his state’s boom? No, and few liberals would claim otherwise. What we’ve been seeing at both the national and the state level is mainly a natural process of recovery as the economy finally starts to heal from the housing and debt bubbles of the Bush years.

But recent job growth, nonetheless, has big political implications — implications so disturbing to many on the right that they are in frantic denial, claiming that the recovery is somehow bogus. Why can’t they handle the good news? The answer actually comes on three levels: Obama Derangement Syndrome, or O.D.S.; Reaganolatry; and the confidence con.

Not much need be said about O.D.S. It is, by now, a fixed idea on the right that this president is both evil and incompetent, that everything touched by the atheist Islamic Marxist Kenyan Democrat — mostly that last item — must go terribly wrong. When good news arrives about the budget, or the economy, or Obamacare — which is, by the way, rapidly reducing the number of uninsured while costing much less than expected — it must be denied.

At a deeper level, modern conservative ideology utterly depends on the proposition that conservatives, and only they, possess the secret key to prosperity. As a result, you often have politicians on the right making claims like this one, from Senator Rand Paul: “When is the last time in our country we created millions of jobs? It was under Ronald Reagan.”

Actually, if creating “millions of jobs” means adding two million or more jobs in a given year, we’ve done that 13 times since Reagan left office: eight times under Bill Clinton, twice under George W. Bush, and three times, so far, under Barack Obama. But who’s counting?

Still, don’t liberals have similar delusions? Not really. The economy added 23 million jobs under Clinton, compared with 16 million under Reagan, but there’s nothing on the left comparable to the cult of the Blessed Ronald. That’s because liberals don’t need to claim that their policies will produce spectacular growth. All they need to claim is feasibility: that we can do things like, say, guaranteeing health insurance to everyone without killing the economy. Conservatives, on the other hand, want to block such things and, instead, to cut taxes on the rich and slash aid to the less fortunate. So they must claim both that liberal policies are job killers and that being nice to the rich is a magic elixir.

One enduring puzzle of political economy is why business interests so often oppose policies to fight unemployment. After all, boosting the economy with expansionary monetary and fiscal policy is good for profits as well as wages, yet many wealthy individuals and business leaders demand tight money and austerity instead.

As a number of observers have pointed out, however, for big businesses to admit that government policies can create jobs would be to devalue one of their favorite political arguments — the claim that to achieve prosperity politicians must preserve business confidence, among other things, by refraining from any criticism of what businesspeople do.

In the case of the Obama economy, this kind of thinking led to what I like to call the “Ma! He’s looking at me funny!” theory of sluggish recovery. By this I mean the insistence that recovery wasn’t being held back by objective factors like spending cuts and debt overhang, but rather by the corporate elite’s hurt feelings after Mr. Obama suggested that some bankers behaved badly and some executives might be overpaid. Who knew that moguls and tycoons were such sensitive souls? In any case, however, that theory is unsustainable in the face of a recovery that has finally started to deliver big job gains, even if it should have happened sooner.

So, as I said at the beginning, the fact that we’re now seeing mornings in blue America — solid job growth both at the national level and in states that have defied the right’s tax-cutting, deregulatory orthodoxy — is a big problem for conservatives. Although they would never admit it, events have proved their most cherished beliefs wrong.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/27/opinion/paul-krugman-mornings-in-blue-america.html?_r=0
Click to expand...

BrieflySpeaking · Mar 27, 2015

got a link for this? trying to share it on social media

gifford1967 · Mar 28, 2015

BrieflySpeaking said: ↑

got a link for this? trying to share it on social media
Click to expand...

Yep. I edited the post.

rudan · Mar 28, 2015

I am paying $2000 more a year than I paid 2 years ago. I was hoping they would create some jobs with my money. Mornings in blue america sounds depressing, i hope they dont kill themselves

Nook · Mar 31, 2015

rudan said: ↑

I am paying $2000 more a year than I paid 2 years ago. I was hoping they would create some jobs with my money. Mornings in blue america sounds depressing, i hope they dont kill themselves
Click to expand...

You have the mental capacity to hold a job?

Good for you!

fchowd0311 · Mar 31, 2015

Nook said: ↑

You have the mental capacity to hold a job?

Good for you!
Click to expand...

You didn't know? Rudan is actually Stephen Colbert. He's actually quite intelligent.

thumbs · Apr 1, 2015

The prospect of waking up in a blue America really makes me ... blue.

Mr. Clutch · Apr 1, 2015

Thanks austerity!

magnetik · Apr 1, 2015

"Mornings in Blue America" hmmm sounds legit.

thumbs · Apr 1, 2015

Mr. Clutch said: ↑

Thanks austerity!
Click to expand...

Funny, back in the Cold War era, the thought of waking up in a Red America made me ... see red.

mc mark · Apr 1, 2015

The Washington Post confirms: Obamacare was a major reason why an estimated 50,000 patient deaths were prevented in 2014.

KingCheetah · Apr 1, 2015

Compare 2008 with 2015... SCOREBOARD

Forums

Mornings in Blue America

gifford1967 Contributing Member
Supporting Member

BrieflySpeaking Contributing Member

gifford1967 Contributing Member
Supporting Member

rudan Member

Nook Member

fchowd0311 Contributing Member

thumbs Contributing Member

Mr. Clutch Contributing Member

magnetik Contributing Member

thumbs Contributing Member

mc mark Contributing Member

KingCheetah Contributing Member

Share This Page

About ClutchFans

Rockets Content

Support ClutchFans!

Mornings in Blue America

gifford1967 Contributing Member Supporting Member

BrieflySpeaking Contributing Member

gifford1967 Contributing Member Supporting Member

rudan Member

Nook Member

fchowd0311 Contributing Member

thumbs Contributing Member

Mr. Clutch Contributing Member

magnetik Contributing Member

thumbs Contributing Member

mc mark Contributing Member

KingCheetah Contributing Member

Share This Page

gifford1967 Contributing Member
Supporting Member

gifford1967 Contributing Member
Supporting Member