Watson Overall, B- Poised. Throws a catchable ball. Made all the throws. Accurate on short and intermediate routes Never a pull it back moment. Slides Did not look overwhelmed by speed of game. Sound throwing mechanics Criticism: Almost everything was out of the shotgun. Which is fine if that's your offense, but you lose some deception. Missed some clear big opportunities downfield. I think you got a good one. The Division has some very good, but not yet great QB's. I would start him right away as long he won't take a beating back there. Also though David Carr did a nice job on set. He's himself which is what you want. Not just saying the same old thing.
Those would be my changes to what you wrote. I still say B-, but he had serious problems with accuracy and footwork.
I like Riley McCarron a lot. He got open quite a few times. He can be our WesWelker/HunterRenfrow. Works out too good for Watson.
